Gross vs Net Rental Yield in Mexico: Real Numbers

Quick answer: Mexico listings quote gross yield (rent ÷ price). Investors live on net yield after 20–35% management, HOA, taxes, and vacancy. A 7% gross Playa condo often nets ~4% — always model all-in purchase cost, not price alone.

Brokers are not lying when they say 7%. They are just stopping the math before the part that hurts. This guide shows the conversion mechanics with worked examples so you can compare Mexico to Florida, bonds, or leaving cash idle — apples to apples.

Master tables: Mexico Rental Yield Guide.

---

The two formulas

Gross yield = Annual gross rent ÷ purchase price

Net yield   = (Gross rent − all operating costs) ÷ all-in cost

All-in cost = price + closing (typically 5–10%).

---

Standard expense lines

Mexico STR operating expenses typically consume 40–60% of gross rent — management takes 20–35%, HOA runs USD 100–900 monthly, plus fideicomiso fees, insurance, predial, cleaning, and vacancy reserves. The expense stack explains why 7% gross yields often net 4% or less. Model every line item rather than assuming US expense ratios apply to Mexican markets.

Expense	Typical	Notes
STR management	20–35% of gross	Full-service STR
Cleaning	Per turn or bundled	Ask manager
HOA	$100–900/mo	Building-specific
Predial	Low annual	Still model it
Fideicomiso	$500–800/yr	Coastal foreign
Insurance	$600–2,400/yr	STR rider
Vacancy	10–25% effective	Seasonality
Lodging tax	City %	Compliance cost

---

Worked example: 7% gross → 4.2% net

This USD 300,000 Playa condo generating USD 21,000 gross rent (7% on price) nets only USD 9,310 after expenses — 2.9% on all-in cost. Management fees consume USD 5,880, HOA takes USD 3,360, and other costs add USD 2,450. With optimistic occupancy assumptions, net yield reaches 4% — the realistic Playa Centro band for 1BR STR units.

Assumptions: $300K price, $18K closing, $318K all-in. Gross rent $21K/year (7% on price).

Line	USD
Gross rent	$21,000
Management 28%	−$5,880
HOA $280×12	−$3,360
Predial + trust + ins	−$1,400
Vacancy reserve 5%	−$1,050
NOI	$9,310
Net on all-in	$9,310 ÷ $318K = 2.9%

Add occupancy optimism or under 25% management and net rises toward 4% — the Playa Centro base case band.

---

Why gross persists in marketing

• Simple mental math for buyers
• Hides HOA variance across buildings
• Occupancy assumptions flexible
• Competitive pressure among brokers
• Developers sell lifestyle + appreciation, not IRR

Your job: convert every pitch to net before offer.

---

Gross/net by market type

Playa Centro 1BR condos typically deliver 6–7% gross and 4–5% net yields, while Tulum Region 15 shows 5.5–6.5% gross but only 2.5–3.5% net due to higher HOA costs and vacancy rates. Cabos branded properties often quote 4–7% gross but net 3–4% after premium management fees. Market selection drives the gross-to-net conversion ratio.

Market type	Gross band	Net band
Playa Centro 1BR	6–7%	4–5%
Tulum Region 15	5.5–6.5%	2.5–3.5%
Cabos branded	4–7%	3–4%
PV Centro	5–7%	3.5–5%

---

Sensitivity table ( $300K, $21K gross )

HOA fees create the largest swing in net yield outcomes — the same USD 21,000 gross rent nets 4.8% with USD 200 monthly HOA but only 2.5% with USD 500 monthly fees. Management rates matter less than building selection since most operators charge 25–30% in competitive markets. Choose buildings by total expense load, not gross rent potential alone.

Management %	HOA/mo	Approx net
20%	$200	4.8%
25%	$280	4.0%
30%	$350	3.2%
30%	$500	2.5%

HOA is the silent dial — same gross, wildly different net.

---

Red flags in pro formas

Developer pro formas often assume 85% occupancy without track record, quote 15% management estimates when reality is 25–30%, omit HOA or lowball at USD 150 on luxury towers, skip vacancy reserves entirely, and use price-only denominators inflating yield by 30–50 basis points. Any two red flags mean the pro forma is marketing fiction rather than investment analysis.

• 85% occupancy with no track record
• 15% management “estimate”
• HOA omitted or “$150” on luxury tower
• No vacancy line
• Price-only denominator
• MXN rent in USD-priced purchase without FX

---

Compare to alternatives correctly

Mexico investment returns must be compared on after-tax net yield basis — US Florida condos after state and federal income tax, S&P dividends accounting for liquidity and hassle premiums, and Mexico properties after both Mexican and US tax obligations. Gross yield comparisons mislead since tax treatment and operating expense structures vary dramatically between jurisdictions.

Asset	Compare on
US Florida condo	Net after US tax, insurance
S&P dividend	Liquidity + no hassle
Mexico Playa	Net after MX + US tax (CPA)

Mexico vs Florida.

---

Action checklist

Convert every broker pitch from gross to net yield using five mandatory steps — request 24-month operating history from seller, obtain written management quotes at realistic 25–30% rates, pull 12 months of HOA statements plus recent minutes, calculate on all-in cost including closing rather than price alone, and stress-test at 60% occupancy for conservative base case. No exceptions for “hot” deals.

1. Request 24-month operating history from seller
2. Get management quote in writing
3. Pull HOA last 12 months + minutes
4. Use all-in cost denominator
5. Stress-test at 60% occupancy

---

Step-by-step: convert any pro forma to net

Transform every broker pitch into realistic net yield using this four-step manual process — normalize revenue using conservative occupancy rather than peak projections, subtract variable operating costs at market rates, deduct fixed annual expenses from actual building data, then divide NOI by all-in purchase cost. Skip these steps at your financial peril.

Use this sequence on every broker deck:

Step 1 — Normalise revenue

Nightly rate × occupied nights = gross rent
Occupied nights = 365 × occupancy %

Example: $140 ADR × (365 × 0.68) = $34,748 gross.

Step 2 — Subtract variable operating

Variable costs scale with occupancy and gross rent — management typically consumes 25–30% of gross (not the 15% brokers quote), cleaning averages USD 50–80 per turnover, lodging taxes run 2–4% of gross in most Riviera Maya municipalities, and platform fees add 3% unless bundled in management contracts. These costs are inevitable, not optional.

Line	Formula
Management	Gross × 25–30%
Cleaning	Turns × fee (if not in mgmt)
Lodging tax	City % × gross
Platform fees	If not in mgmt contract

Step 3 — Subtract fixed annual

Fixed annual expenses hit regardless of occupancy — HOA fees are building-specific and range from USD 100–900 monthly, predial runs USD 200–800 yearly, fideicomiso costs USD 500–800 annually, STR insurance with liability riders costs USD 800–2,000 yearly, and repairs reserves should equal 5–8% of gross rent. These costs compound to significantly impact net yield.

Line	Typical
HOA × 12	Building-specific
Predial	$200–800/yr
Fideicomiso	$500–800/yr
Insurance STR rider	$800–2,000/yr
Repairs reserve	5–8% gross

Step 4 — Divide by all-in cost

NOI ÷ (price + closing) = net yield

Full calculator walkthrough: How to Calculate Rental Yield Mexico.

---

Three buildings, same gross, different net

HOA fees create dramatic net yield variations even within the same neighborhood — Building A with USD 180 monthly HOA nets 4.6% while Building B with USD 420 monthly HOA nets only 3.1% despite identical gross yields and purchase prices. Building C faces STR ban, delivering 0% net regardless of potential. Choose buildings by expense load, not just location.

Same colonia, same $300K price — HOA kills the spread:

Building	Gross	HOA/mo	Mgmt	Net
A — older Centro	7.0%	$180	25%	4.6%
B — new tower	7.0%	$420	28%	3.1%
C — STR-banned	0%	$250	—	0%

Building selection is yield selection. Gross marketing hides HOA spread.

---

Seasonality: annualise correctly

Riviera Maya occupancy varies dramatically by season — November through April high season achieves 75–85% in prime Centro locations, while July-August hurricane season drops to 50–65% despite being North American summer. Underwriting December performance at 90% and multiplying by 12 creates fantasy projections. Use 12-month trailing data or conservative 65–70% annual averages.

Riviera Maya occupancy curves are not flat:

Month band	Occupancy signal
Nov–Apr high	75–85% prime Centro
May–Jun shoulder	60–70%
Jul–Aug hurricane season	50–65%
Sep–Oct variable	55–70%

Mistake: Underwriting December only at 90% and multiplying by 12. Fix: Use 12-month trailing or conservative 65–70% base.

Playa depth: Invest in Playa del Carmen.

---

Management fee tiers: what you get

Management fees correlate with service levels — 15–20% typically covers basic turnover but excludes marketing and permits, 22–28% includes full STR operations but not major repairs, while 30–35% provides premium concierge services. The cheapest manager is rarely the cheapest operation since permit fines, vacancy, and guest issues cost more than fee spreads between providers.

Fee %	Usually includes	Often excludes
15–20%	Basic turnover	Marketing, permits
22–28%	Full STR ops	Major repairs
30–35%	Premium concierge	—

Cheapest manager is not cheapest operation — permit fines and vacancy cost more than fee spread.

Management costs: Property Management Riviera Maya Cost.

---

Taxes in the net yield stack

Tax obligations reduce cash in pocket below NOI — predial is minimal but lodging/hospitality municipal taxes eat into operations, Mexican income tax on rent hits active operators, and US worldwide reporting captures American investors. Underwriting at 4.5% NOI pre-tax when your marginal rate captures 30%+ of rent fundamentally changes investment decisions versus tax-free alternatives.

Mexican and home-country tax treatment affects cash in pocket, not always the same as NOI:

Tax	Effect on net
Predial	Low — include in NOI
Lodging / hospitality municipal	Reduce NOI
Mexican income tax on rent	Cash after tax
US worldwide reporting	After-tax to US investor

Tax framing: Mexico Property Taxes Explained. US angle: Mexico Property for Americans.

Underwriting at 4.5% NOI pre-tax when your marginal rate captures 30%+ of rent changes the decision.

---

Gross/net spread by property type

Property type determines expense stack and net yield compression — Playa Centro 1BR units show moderate 200–300 basis point gross-to-net spreads due to reasonable HOA costs, while Tulum Region 15 suffers 300–400 basis point compression from high HOA fees and vacancy rates. Cabos branded properties face premium management and HOA costs that compress margins despite strong ADRs.

Type	Typical gross	Typical net	Spread driver
Playa Centro 1BR	6–7%	4–5%	HOA moderate
Tulum R15 1BR	5.5–6.5%	2.5–3.5%	HOA high + vacancy
Cabos branded 1BR	4–7%	3–4%	Premium HOA
PV Centro 1BR	5–7%	3.5–5%	Seasonality
Long-term rent Mérida	4–5%	3–4%	Lower mgmt %

---

Developer pro forma red team

Developer pro formas require line-by-line challenge — verify ADR against AirDNA or operator data for the specific building rather than city averages, demand 12-month occupancy data not peak month projections, obtain written management quotes at 28% rather than accepting 15% placeholders, and request post-construction HOA estimates for pre-delivery purchases. If net yield survives this red team exercise, proceed to due diligence.

Challenge every line:

1. ADR — compare AirDNA or operator data for building, not city average
2. Occupancy — require 12-month not peak month
3. Management — quote in writing at 28%, not 15% placeholder
4. HOA — request post-construction estimate if pre-construction
5. Competition — count identical units on STR platforms within 500m

If net still clears hurdle after red team — proceed to DD. If not — pass without guilt.

---

Spreadsheet template (manual)

Build your own net yield calculator by filling this template for every property — input purchase price, add 7% closing costs, calculate gross rent from ADR and occupancy, subtract management percentage, deduct annual HOA and other fixed costs, then divide NOI by all-in cost. Stress-test by reducing occupancy 10% and increasing HOA 20% — if the thesis survives, make an offer.

Row	Your unit
Purchase price
Closing (7%)
All-in cost
ADR
Occupancy %
Gross rent
Management %
HOA annual
Other opex
NOI
Net yield

Stress occupancy at −10% and HOA at +20% — if thesis survives, offer.

---

When gross yield still matters

Gross is a screening tool — not underwriting:

• Quick filter among 20 listings
• Relative comparison within same building
• Developer ranking before deep DD

Convert to net before offer — always.

---

Platform economics: Airbnb vs long-term in net terms

Long-term rentals sometimes net similarly to STR with lower regulatory risk — USD 1,200 monthly LTR gross with 10% management can produce USD 12,200 NOI, matching STR performance after 28% management and higher vacancy reserves. STR upside comes from ADR spikes during high season; downside includes HOA STR bans and municipal compliance burdens that LTR avoids.

Model	$300K Playa 1BR indicative NOI
STR gross $21K, mgmt 28%, HOA $3.6K	~$11.5K NOI
LTR gross $14.4K ($1,200/mo), mgmt 10%	~$12.2K NOI

Long-term rent sometimes nets similarly with less regulatory risk — if HOA allows and municipal rules fit. STR upside is ADR spikes in high season; downside is ban risk.

Airbnb Investment Mexico.

---

Cabos and PV net compression examples

Cabos branded $450K all-in, gross $27K

After mgmt 30% and HOA $9,600/yr → NOI ~$9.3K → ~2.1% net unless appreciation carries thesis.

PV Centro $340K all-in, gross $19K

After mgmt 25% and HOA $4.2K → NOI ~$10K → ~2.9% net — lifestyle and retiree demand support hold.

Pacific markets often trade net for stability — not RM Playa maths.

---

Five questions to ask every seller pro forma

Validate seller pro formas with five essential questions — request actual gross revenue for the last 12 months via CFDI or manager reports, confirm management contract rates are signed not estimated, obtain HOA statements for the last 3 months plus any special assessment votes, count identical units operating STR in the building, and verify municipal STR registration numbers if any. No answers means the pro forma is fiction.

1. What was actual gross last 12 months — CFDI or manager report?
2. Management contract rate — signed or estimated?
3. HOA last 3 months — any special assessment votes?
4. How many identical units STR in building?
5. Municipal STR registration number — if any?

No answers → pro forma is fiction.

---

IRR vs yield: hold period matters

Net yield captures annual cash flow but IRR includes closing cost amortization over hold period, special assessments, exit taxes, and appreciation or depreciation. A 4% net yield property with 3% annual appreciation delivers stronger total return over five years than 4% net with flat pricing. Short hold periods magnify closing cost drag on IRR calculations.

Net yield is annual snapshot — internal rate of return includes:

• Closing cost amortised over hold years
• Special assessments
• Sale ISR and US tax on exit
• Appreciation or depreciation

Hold	4% net + 3% appreciation	4% net flat price
5 yr	Stronger total return	4% annual only
2 yr	Closing hurts IRR	Thin

Short hold magnifies closing drag — Cost of Buying.

---

Break-even occupancy formula

Break-even occ = Fixed costs ÷ (ADR × 365 × (1 − mgmt%))

Example: fixed $11K, ADR $130, mgmt 25%:

Break-even occ ≈ 38% — below this NOI negative. Know your floor before buying.

---

Building amenities vs net: rooftop pool case

Premium amenities like rooftop pools increase HOA costs by USD 80–150 monthly but may only add USD 25 to ADR — creating neutral or negative net yield impact. A pool building with USD 340 monthly HOA often nets the same 4.0% as basic buildings with USD 220 HOA despite higher ADR. Amenities sell lifestyle but spreadsheets reveal economic truth.

Rooftop pool adds $80–150/mo HOA but may add $25 ADR — net math:

	No pool HOA $220	Pool HOA $340
ADR	$125	$150
Occ 65%	4.1% net	4.0% net

Amenity sometimes neutral on net — marketing sells lifestyle, spreadsheet sells truth.

---

Related

• Invest in Playa
• Riviera Maya
• Due Diligence
• Playa Area

---

Worked example 2: Cabos branded $450K

This premium Cabos property shows how luxury markets compress net yields — USD 27,000 gross rent (6% on price) becomes USD 7,700 NOI after 30% management and USD 9,000 annual HOA, delivering only 1.6% net on all-in cost of USD 481,000. Premium markets often require appreciation thesis since rental yields alone rarely justify purchase prices.

Line	USD
Gross 6% on price	$27,000
Mgmt 30%	−$8,100
HOA $750/mo	−$9,000
Other	−$2,200
NOI	$7,700
All-in $481K	1.6% net

Premium market — appreciation thesis often required.

---

Worked example 3: Puerto Vallarta $330K

Puerto Vallarta markets benefit from retiree and long-stay demand that supports higher occupancy with lower management costs — USD 19,500 gross with 25% management and USD 320 monthly HOA produces USD 9,200 NOI for 2.6% net on USD 353,000 all-in cost. Adjust expectations for demographic-driven markets where stability matters more than peak yield.

Line	USD
Gross $19,500
Mgmt 25%	−$4,875
HOA $320/mo	−$3,840
NOI	~$9,200
All-in $353K	2.6% net

Retiree demand supports long-stay mix — adjust ADR down, occupancy up.

---

Summary table: gross to net quick reference

Use these market benchmarks for quick screening — Playa Centro delivers the strongest net yields at 4–5% from 6–7% gross, Tulum areas show significant compression to 2.5–4.5% net from similar gross rates, while Cabos branded properties rarely exceed 3–4% net despite higher-end positioning. Verify building-specific data rather than relying on market medians for final decisions.

Market	Typical gross	Typical net
Playa Centro	6–7%	4–5%
Tulum R15	5.5–6.5%	2.5–3.5%
Tulum AZ	6–7%	3.5–4.5%
Cabos branded	4–7%	3–4%

Always verify building — table is colonia median not guarantee.

---

Investor takeaway

Gross yield is marketing; net yield is decision. Convert every pitch before offer using all-in cost, 25–30% management, real HOA, and 65–70% occupancy unless proven otherwise.

How to Calculate Rental Yield Mexico — step-by-step workbook.

---

Document retention for yield disputes

Keep seller pro forma, manager quote, HOA statements, and your spreadsheet — if net misses projection year 1, data determines whether manager underperformed or model was wrong.

---

Closing rule

If you remember one thing: divide NOI by all-in cost after 25–30% management and real HOA — every Mexico yield conversation starts and ends there.

---

Examples illustrative. Mexico Invest does not provide investment advice.